I often wonder why it is that we, as a species, spend so much energy thinking about things that only matter when we imagine ourselves to be in some sort of extreme situation, even though we spend most of our time nowhere near the ends of the earth.
On his television program The Day The Universe Changed, James Burke repeated a story. It seems that someone once observed to the philosopher Wittgenstein how stupid medieval Europeans living before the time of Copernicus must have been that they could have looked up at the sky and thought that the sun was going around the earth. Wittgenstein was said to have replied yes, but I wonder what it would have looked like if the sun had been going around the earth? The answer is, of course, that it would have looked identical. It is only because we are told what is "actually going on" that makes us think as we do.
There are some folks who still believe the earth is flat. For the most part, observation would agree with them. I've been in a plane at 30,000 feet and it only seems to be slightly curved, but I suspect I noticed that because I believe we live on a huge globe. It must be discouraging for that group that nobody has ever taken snaps while standing at the ends of the earth, which I think they believe to be along the Antarctic ridge that circles the earth with a circumference of ... oh well, never mind that. And let's not even get started on the great space program hoax that has been foisted on us all. The National Enquirer is missing a trick there for sure.
Darwin's observations on the origin of species caused an uproar because they eventually changed the way most of us think about natural history. I do have to wonder, though, for the average person, why it matters whether species have evolved or species were created in an instant by some supernatural power.
The belief that the earth is a globe doesn't make us do anything differently, apart from airline pilots who plot great circle routes believing it will save fuel. The sun still "rises" and "sets" for everyone apart from those who live in the far north or south, and that circling about phenomenon can be explained - somehow - I guess.
More particularly, I often wonder why I spend so much energy wondering about those sort of things, when, quite obviously, so many of my fellow travellers on this orb seem to be absorbed by more immediate and important things; things such as what some movie star is wearing, or who they are courting, or what team is winning on some "reality" game show, or how a favourite sports team is doing.
At the moment, two young men who are the subject of a manhunt in northern Manitoba desperately need an epiphany to help them live a bit longer. If we believe the news, just for kicks, they murdered three people along highways in British Columbia, then fled in a stolen SUV across the prairies toward the east. I'm not really sure what to do with that information.
I believe all of this stuff (about how planets move because of the curvature of space-time for instance), and yet for all the wonderful-yet-not-very-applicable beliefs I have, none of it does me a bit of good when trying to help my children and the rest of humanity cope with this crazy world.
I do have some spiritual beliefs that protect me, in the very long term, from falling into despair, but they are ends of the earth beliefs, not here-and-now-I-can-help-everyone-get-through-this-trauma beliefs.
Just in case you need to escape from reality (some fuzzy bunny distraction as Coline and I call it) here is a link to a topic that is so unimportant to the daily lives of people on the planet as to be laughable. I will admit to being fascinated by it all. It makes me happy to visualize the planets circling about - the earth rotating once a day with its moon slowly circling. It helps me to think there are things I might actually understand. I definitely cannot fathom a world where those two young people managed to come to this end; hiding from death at the hands of so many soldiers and police, somewhere near the ends of the earth.
So sorry - forgot to include the link in my original reply!
ReplyDelete***
Thoughtful post as always, Miss D. It made me think of this song by Mark Erelli, a folksinger from the Boston area.
In addition to being a brilliant songwriter, he also possesses a Masters degree in evolutionary biology. He incorporates that background into this remarkable song, which is sung from the point of view of Charles Darwin. It's called "Kingdom Come."
https://youtu.be/FE5fTV69ocw
== Cass
So poignant dear Cass. Thank you.
DeleteI'm glad you liked it, Deanna. Here's another beauty from Mr. Erelli. This one is a cover version written by the late, great Bill Morrissey, another superb New England songwriter. He sort of adopted Mark when he was starting out; Mark returned the favor by recording an entire album of Morrissey songs called Milltowns. Here's one from that album- "Long Gone."
Deletehttps://youtu.be/HAZWNFTEz7k
== Cass
Listening to Mark reminds me of another great American singer of rhymes - Paul Simon.
DeleteI don't think the Earth is curved; it's just very bumpy, not flat. That is why I must get out on the garden today to effect - at least to some degree - that change in soil profile.
ReplyDeleteSo glad to hear the temperature has moderated and you can be out in that bumpy garden.
DeleteHi Halle,
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand one can argue in the end what it feels like is all that really matters, even at the sharp end of handing out justice. What matters and what we think can’t be all about the here and now, for I would take issue that maybe you are being a bit too hard on yourself , or me , or anyone else for that matter that likes thinking about things that consensus so called common sense suggests has nothing to do with this crazy world. For I think it does , even if it is only to bring a sense of humility and wonder about what we feel we don’t know. I enjoyed reading the material in the link, keep gazing up at the stars and wondering, it may provide food for thought you can share with your children,
Best wishes
Hi Lindsay,
DeleteIt seems unlikely that any joy or wisdom will come from dwelling upon the world built for the masses and run by the monied few. I will continue to let my dreams guide me.
And there is much wisdom on which to ponder in your latest reply.
ReplyDelete